November 18, 2026
Traffic Stop Evidence: Field Tests vs. Chemical Analysis in DUI Cases
By @safedrivedigest
When a driver is pulled over on suspicion of impaired driving, the evidence that later appears in court begins to form long before any arrest. From the moment the patrol lights go on, a sequence of observations and tests starts building the case. Understanding where each piece of evidence comes from and how it differs from the next can help someone facing a DUI charge make sense of what happened and what may come next.
Three broad categories of evidence typically emerge from a DUI traffic stop: the officer’s observations during the stop, the results of field sobriety tests, and the chemical analysis of breath or blood. Each type has its own strengths and weaknesses, and each can be challenged in different ways. A careful review of DUI evidence often starts with the traffic stop itself and moves through the testing process step by step.
The Traffic Stop: Where the Record Begins
The initial stop is the foundation of everything that follows. An officer must have reasonable suspicion that a traffic violation or some other unlawful activity has occurred. That might be swerving, speeding, a broken headlight, or any observable infraction. Once the stop is made, the officer watches for signs of impairment: slurred speech, the smell of alcohol, bloodshot eyes, or unusual behavior.
Body camera footage is now common in many jurisdictions, and it captures the stop from start to finish. This footage can show the driver’s coordination, their responses to questions, and the overall tone of the encounter. It also records whether the officer followed proper procedure. If the officer did not have a valid reason for the stop, or if the body camera footage contradicts the officer’s report, the entire case may be affected. The stop itself is the first piece of evidence, and its legality can determine whether later evidence is admissible.
Field Sobriety Tests: Voluntary but Telling
After the stop, the officer may ask the driver to perform field sobriety tests. These are physical exercises designed to measure balance, coordination, and the ability to follow instructions. Common examples include the walk-and-turn, the one-leg stand, and the horizontal gaze nystagmus test, where the officer watches the eyes for involuntary jerking.

Field tests are considered voluntary in many states. A driver can refuse them, though that refusal may carry consequences such as a license suspension. The tests themselves are not perfectly reliable. Fatigue, nervousness, medical conditions, uneven pavement, or even the type of shoes a person is wearing can affect performance. The officer’s training and how they administer the test also matter. A properly administered test follows a strict protocol, and any deviation can create reasonable doubt.
Because field sobriety tests are subjective and open to interpretation, they often become a central point of contention. An experienced DUI defense attorney will look closely at how the tests were conducted and whether the officer followed the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) guidelines. If the officer rushed through the instructions or failed to account for the driver’s physical limitations, the results may be unreliable.
Breath Testing: A Snapshot of BAC
If the officer has probable cause to believe the driver is impaired, they may request a breath test. The most common device is the breathalyzer, which measures the alcohol concentration in the breath and estimates the blood alcohol concentration (BAC). This test is usually administered at the station after the arrest, though some officers use portable preliminary breath test devices at the roadside.
Breath tests are chemical tests, but they are not infallible. The machine must be properly calibrated and maintained, and the operator must be trained. Things like mouth alcohol from recent burping or vomiting, certain medical conditions, or the presence of substances like mouthwash can produce false high readings. The timing of the test also matters. BAC rises after drinking stops, so a test taken too late may show a higher level than existed at the time of driving.
Because breath tests are a form of chemical analysis, they carry more weight than field tests in court. But they are still subject to challenge. A DUI defense attorney may request the machine’s maintenance records, the operator’s certification, and the calibration logs. If any of these are missing or show irregularities, the test results may be excluded.
Blood Draw: The Most Direct Measure
In some cases, particularly when a driver refuses a breath test or when there is an accident with injuries, the police may obtain a warrant for a blood draw. A blood sample is taken by a trained professional and sent to a lab for analysis. This method directly measures the blood alcohol concentration and is generally considered more accurate than a breath test.

But blood evidence has its own vulnerabilities. The chain of custody is critical. The sample must be collected, stored, transported, and analyzed without contamination or mix-up. If the chain of custody is broken, the evidence may be unreliable. The lab itself must follow proper procedures, and the technician who analyzes the sample must be qualified. Errors in labeling, storage temperature, or testing methods can all affect the result.
A thorough review of DUI evidence will include an examination of the blood draw procedure and the lab’s handling of the sample. If the police did not obtain a proper warrant, or if the blood was drawn without valid consent, the evidence may be suppressed. Even when the blood draw is lawful, mistakes in the lab can create reasonable doubt.
How the Pieces Fit Together
Each type of evidence tells part of the story. The traffic stop provides context. The field tests suggest impairment, but they are subjective. The breath or blood test offers a numerical BAC, but only if the testing was done correctly. A prosecutor will try to present these pieces as a clear picture of guilt. A defense attorney’s job is to examine each piece for flaws and to show where the picture is incomplete.
For example, if the officer did not have probable cause for the stop, any evidence gathered after that point may be inadmissible. If the field tests were done on an uneven surface or without proper instruction, the results may be misleading. If the breathalyzer was not calibrated, the BAC reading may be inaccurate. And if the blood sample was mishandled, it may not be reliable at all.
The law allows for these challenges because the stakes are high. A DUI conviction can mean fines, license suspension, higher insurance rates, and even jail time. It can affect employment, professional licenses, and personal reputation. Being able to question the evidence is not a loophole. It is a fundamental part of ensuring a fair process.
What This Means for Someone Facing a DUI
If you are stopped and asked to perform field tests, it helps to know that you have rights. You are not required to answer incriminating questions. You can politely decline to perform the field sobriety tests, though you should be aware of the consequences in your state. You cannot refuse a chemical test without a penalty under implied consent laws, but you can ask to speak with an attorney before deciding.

After an arrest, the evidence will be compiled by the prosecution. You do not have to face that evidence alone. An attorney who understands how each piece of evidence is gathered and tested can identify weaknesses and build a defense. Whether the case goes to trial or ends in a plea, the quality of the evidence matters.
From the moment the patrol car’s lights come on to the final analysis of a blood sample, every step in the process leaves a trail. Understanding that trail is the first step toward protecting your rights.
❧